India doesn’t often lose T20Is by 50 runs at home, and when they do, it’s rarely because of a single bad over or one freak collapse. Vizag, however, was different. It felt… avoidable. Almost self-inflicted.
A 3-game sweep of New Zealand, sealed in their last win, gave India some flexibility to try something new for the fourth T20I rather than simply continue the same lineup that they had used all along. The injury to Ishan Kishan left an easy vacancy at No. 3. Shreyas Iyer was available but did not get the call-up to replace him. In place of the most logical replacement, India called up Arshdeep Singh to join the bowling attack; this resulted in very thin batting and an order that was jumbled.
A Missed Safety Net at No.3
With Ishan Kishan’s injury, India had a chance to get Shreyas Iyer some experience in a low-risk, high-reward way, as Iyer may not have been included in the World Cup squad, while Tilak Varma’s fitness or form was uncertain, as he has not played since January 6.
India has been burned before by assuming players will “slot right back in.” Sanju Samson’s stop-start returns to the XI are proof that rhythm cannot be manufactured on tournament day. In this context, Iyer was effectively an unofficial reserve experienced, proven at No.3, and tailor-made to stabilize innings.
Instead, India chose to test itself artificially. The result? A fragile top order with no glue between aggression and control. With Tilak unavailable and Iyer sidelined, India weakened their own contingency planning, an odd move so close to a global tournament.
Batting Depth Philosophy Turned Upside Down
Under Gautam Gambhir, India’s white-ball blueprint has been crystal clear: batting depth is non-negotiable. Bowlers have routinely been selected for their ability to contribute at No.8, sometimes even at the expense of bowling specialization.
Replacing Kishan with Arshdeep Singh shortened the batting to No.6, forcing Harshit Rana in at No.7, followed by a long tail. Predictably, India couldn’t bat out their overs. Half the side was gone before the halfway mark, and suddenly the chase turned into survival mode disguised as aggression.
Chasing a big total with a batter short removes the option of pacing an innings. India had to swing hard from ball one, not by design, but by necessity. Experiments are fine, but momentum is fragile. One heavy defeat can undo weeks of confidence-building, especially in T20 cricket.
A Batting Order Without Anchors
Beyond numbers, roles matter, and this is where the exclusion of Shreyas Iyer hurt the most.
Iyer is a natural bridge between the top and middle order. Without him, India’s lineup resembled a jigsaw forced together without corner pieces. Abhishek Sharma fell first ball, and chaos followed.
Rinku Singh batted far earlier than his World Cup role demands. Hardik Pandya walked in during the seventh over. Harshit Rana appeared just after the halfway mark. None of these entry points align with how India plans to function at full strength.
Yes, Rinku can adapt. But exposure without context is misleading. Balls faced in the power play do little to prepare a finisher meant to operate at the death. Instead of clarity, India ended up with confusion and an uncoordinated batting collapse disguised as experimentation.
Key Takeaway
India’s Vizag defeat wasn’t bold experimentation; it was structural overconfidence.
FAQs
1. What was India’s biggest mistake in the 4th T20I vs New Zealand?
Ignoring Shreyas Iyer and weakening batting depth.
2. Why was Shreyas Iyer’s exclusion risky?
Because India lacked a stable No.3 amid Tilak Varma’s uncertainty.
3. How did the team’s balance suffer without Iyer?
The batting order lost clarity, forcing players into unfamiliar roles.
Disclaimer: This blog post reflects the author’s personal insights and analysis. Readers are encouraged to consider the perspectives shared and draw their own conclusions.
Step into the world of cricket with JeetBuzz News—where expert opinions, trending Blogs, and behind-the-scenes insights meet all your favorite topics. Stay informed, stay entertained, and never miss the stories shaping the cricketing world—only on JeetBuzz News!
